PDA (Persistent Drive for Autonomy): A Neuro-Affirming Guide and Resources

Smooth pebbles on a quiet shore at sunset. Caption: PDA.

A gentle, research-informed signposting resource about PDA, for PDAers, for Autistic, ADHD and AuDHD people who recognise themselves in these words, and for the families, friends and professionals who walk alongside us. PDA is still debated in research, and the name itself is changing. What is not in doubt is how real the experience is: an intense, whole-body need for autonomy, where everyday demands, even ones we want to do, can feel like a threat (Kildahl et al., 2021; Newson et al., 2003; Stuart et al., 2020).

With thanks to Laura Hellfeld

The community signposting on this page is inspired by, and draws on, Laura Hellfeld’s growing list, PDA Signposting: A Growing List (Hellfeld, 2025). Laura is a neurodivergent nurse (RN, MSN, PHN, CNL) at ND Nurse Consulting. Her list brings together PDAers, families and practitioners, and she adds to it over time. Please visit her original post for the full list, and consider subscribing to support her work.

As Laura says, signposting is in no particular order, and please use your own judgement about any person or organisation listed. You can follow Laura on Facebook, Bluesky and LinkedIn.

For more organisations, practitioners and support, please visit my community signposting page. You can also read the PDA entry in my Neuro-Affirming Glossary.

What is PDA?

PDA was first described by Elizabeth Newson as Pathological Demand Avoidance (Newson et al., 2003). Many PDAers and allies now prefer Persistent or Pervasive Drive for Autonomy, a name proposed by Tomlin Wilding, because it describes what is happening from the inside rather than how it looks from the outside (Hellfeld, 2025; Wilding, 2020).

The PDA Society describes PDA as a profile of autism, in which people share Autistic characteristics and also avoid everyday demands, often using social strategies to do so. PDA is not a separate diagnosis in the DSM-5 or ICD-11, and some services will describe it as “a PDA profile of autism” or “extreme demand avoidance”.

Research is still young. Two systematic reviews found that most studies rely on parent questionnaires built on Newson’s original descriptions, and that the evidence for PDA as a distinct diagnosis is weak (Company & Rotella, 2026; Kildahl et al., 2021). A scoping review reached similar conclusions about research methods (Haire et al., 2024). The debate continues in medical journals (Green, 2024; Woods, 2024). This does not mean the experience is not real. It means research has not yet caught up with what PDAers and families describe, and that PDA voices need to be at the centre of what comes next.

A neuro-affirming lens: whose behaviour is being pathologised?

Allison Moore (2020) asks what, and who, is being pathologised when we call demand avoidance “pathological”, and in whose interests. A resistance to control is a very human response, especially when a child or adult is in an environment that does not fit them. Damian Milton (2013) described PDA as, in part, nature’s answer to over-conformity.

The double empathy problem reminds us that misunderstandings between Autistic and non-Autistic people go both ways (Milton, 2012). Behaviour that looks “defiant” to an adult may be a nervous system protecting itself from loss of control. A neuro-affirming approach moves the question from “how do we get compliance?” to “what does this person need to feel safe and free enough to engage?”

Why demands can feel so big

There is no single explanation, and different ideas may fit different people. Some threads that research and lived experience point to are:

  • Anxiety and uncertainty. Demand avoidance is closely linked with anxiety and with finding uncertainty hard to tolerate. Avoiding a demand can be a way of making the world feel more predictable and safe (Johnson & Saunderson, 2023; Stuart et al., 2020; White et al., 2023).
  • Autonomy and control. A strong need to follow our own agendas, and to feel in control of what happens to us, is tied up with feeling safe (Greaves, 2025).
  • Monotropism. When attention flows deeply into a few interests at a time, a demand can pull us out of a tunnel of attention suddenly and painfully (Murray et al., 2005). You can read more in my monotropism guide.
  • Emotional reactivity and AuDHD. A recent UK clinic study found demand avoidance was linked with emotional reactivity, ADHD traits, cognitive inflexibility, intolerance of uncertainty and alexithymia (difficulty identifying feelings) (Lack et al., 2026). This is a small study, but it reminds us that PDA is not only discussed within autism.
  • Internal demands. Demands are not only from other people. Hunger, thirst, sleep, hygiene and using the toilet can all feel like demands, and this can have a real impact on daily life (Carlozzi, Lai, et al., 2026).

How it can show up

Every PDAer is different. Some things people and families often describe are:

  • Not being able to do something, even something you want to do, once it feels expected. Many PDAers describe this as “can’t, not won’t”
  • Praise, questions, routines, timetables and even invitations feeling like pressure
  • Using humour, distraction, negotiation, role play or fantasy to manage demands
  • Needing to be on an equal footing with others, and finding hierarchy hard
  • Masking at school or work and then collapsing or melting down at home, which is linked with exhaustion and burnout (Pearson & Rose, 2021; Raymaker et al., 2020)
  • School distress and not being able to attend school. In one large UK study, most young people with school attendance difficulties were described as neurodivergent (Connolly et al., 2023)
  • Big swings in capacity from day to day, depending on anxiety, sensory load and energy

What helps: autonomy, trust and connection

Research on what helps is still emerging, so much of what we know comes from PDAers and families. A few gentle threads are:

  • Shared understanding. Mothers of PDA children describe how much it helps when the whole family and the professionals around them share an understanding of PDA (Curtis & Izett, 2025).
  • Lowering demands. Dropping or reducing non-essential demands, so there is more capacity for what really matters, sometimes called low-demand living or parenting (Diekman, 2023).
  • Collaboration over compliance. Working with the person as an equal partner, offering choice, negotiation and flexibility, rather than rewards, sanctions or behaviour charts (Christie et al., 2012; Fidler & Christie, 2019).
  • Indirect and declarative language. Wondering aloud, noticing and inviting (“I wonder if…”, “Something I noticed…”) rather than direct instructions.
  • Reducing uncertainty in ways that feel safe. Predictability the person has chosen, not imposed routines (Stuart et al., 2020).
  • Rest and recovery. Protecting time to recover, especially after school, work or social time. You can read more in my burnout guide.
  • Looking after the adults too. Supporting PDAers is a lot. Parents and carers need support, rest and community of their own (Curtis & Izett, 2025).

Behaviourist approaches, which focus on compliance, can be especially harmful for PDAers, as they increase the very pressure and loss of control that drives distress. You can read more about alternatives to ABA and behaviourism.

Intersectionality: PDA is not one story

Most PDA research has relied on parent reports about children, with far fewer studies listening to PDA adults or to people from racialised, LGBTQIA+ or working-class communities (Haire et al., 2024; Kildahl et al., 2021). Newson’s early work described an equal sex ratio, unlike autism research at the time (Newson et al., 2003).

How demand avoidance is understood often depends on who the person is. Racism, sexism, transphobia and classism all shape whose distress is seen as anxiety and whose is seen as “bad behaviour” (Mallipeddi & VanDaalen, 2022). Masking can hide distress for anyone, and stereotypes about gender affect whose struggles are noticed (Pearson & Rose, 2021). Families have also described long journeys to having PDA recognised and supported (Doyle & Kenny, 2023). Any support needs to honour the whole person, their culture and their context.

What’s new: listening to PDA people

The largest recent survey of PDA people and families, PDA in our words, was designed and tested by PDA Society staff and volunteers who all have lived experience of PDA (PDA Society, 2024). Over 900 PDA children, PDA adults and parents took part. It found that:

  • 60% of parents said their child struggles to get into school regularly or all of the time
  • 77% of PDA adults had experienced financial hardship at some point
  • 84% of PDA adults had experienced suicidal thoughts. This is a painful reminder of how urgently PDA people need understanding and support. If this brings up difficult feelings, please see the support lines further down this page
  • Many families felt that needing a diagnosis was being used to gatekeep support, and called for collaborative approaches

Research is also beginning to work alongside the PDA community. The Paradigm Shift Program, a parent programme developed with At Peace Parents, was found to be acceptable to parents and was linked with improvements in parents’ quality of life (Carlozzi, Lombard, et al., 2026). A new questionnaire, the Demand Avoidance and Autonomy Questionnaire, puts autonomy in its name and includes the impact on basic needs such as eating, sleeping and using the toilet (Carlozzi, Lai, et al., 2026).

PDA adults are increasingly telling their own stories, from Devon Price’s essay I’m Pathologically Demand Avoidant. It Rules. (Price, 2023) to PDA Reflections from a PDAer on PDA North America. You will find more PDA-led voices, podcasts and community work below.

For parents, carers and professionals

  • Start from trust: assume the person is doing the best they can with the capacity they have today
  • Notice and reduce hidden demands, including praise, questions and expectations
  • Offer choice and genuine control, and be willing to let go of things that are not essential
  • Use identity-first, affirming language where people prefer it (Botha et al., 2023)
  • Make room for PDA adults’ voices in training, policy and research
  • Look for neurodivergence-informed support that sees difficulties as relational, not just individual (Chapman & Botha, 2023)

What would you add?

Do you know of PDA-led voices, research, books, blogs or podcasts that should be here, especially from people whose voices are often missing? Like Laura’s list, this guide grows with our community, and I would love to hear from you.

Last reviewed: November 2026

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner